After a long hiatus from simming, last year I bought myself a Logitech Extreme 3D Pro and gave DCS a go. I own the A-10C module but so far I've stuck almost entirely to Black Shark. I have some spare cash and it's only a matter of time before I pick up Elite: Dangerous so I'm thinking of getting my first HOTAS (including rudder pedals).
Based on my research so far I'm leaning towards a CH Products setup. Trouble is I now have the dilemma of choosing between the Combatstick and Fighterstick. From what I've read it seems most people advocate the Fighterstick since it has more buttons in total, but I think I'd much prefer having a simple thumb button like on the 3D Pro to use as my trim button in Black Shark. I imagine using the thumb hat for this would feel very unnatural, and indeed the real KA-50 has a thumb button for this purpose: http://walkarounds.airforce.ru/avia/rus/kamov/ka-50/airforce_ru_ka-50_77.jpg
So my question is, are there any Fighterstick owners out there happily using it to fly the Black Shark? I'm sure the extra hats it provides would come in handy for the other sims I play, but I don't want to get it if it makes it harder to fly my beloved shark.