Wrong with the way the case determining

[Hogeo]

I set the fog with visibility=4.85nm(29,528ft) & thickness=3,000ft, and flew from about 5 DME/2000ft away to see the carrier.

Although I could not see the carrier, the marshal instructed us on Case I recovery.

If the visibility is less than 5nm, the marshal must instruct Case II recovery.

Also, even when the cloud base was 2952ft (900m), the marshal instructed Case I recovery, and even when the cloud base was 984ft (300m), they instructed Case II recovery.

Marshal must instruct Case II if the cloud base is less than 3000 - 1000ft, and instruct Case III if the cloud base is less than 1000ft.

However, it seems that since the standard is based on meter values such as 900m and 300m, it does not work properly with the foot standards described in CV NATOPS and CV PROCEDURES.

When setting the weather, the units are mixed and it's difficult to understand, as even though the panel shows it in feet, the implementation seems to judge it in meters. I would like it to be fixed so that it can be set correctly in the units shown on the panel.

Also, for fog, if the thickness value is small, the fog height is too low, so even if you set the conditions for Case II/III, the marshal may not instruct Case II/III.

In other words, ED will need to not only revise the case judgment logic, but also clearly state the conditions for setting Case II or Case III in the operation manual or somewhere similar.

However, the biggest problem is that despite the fact that these have already been reported, they are giving a response as if there is no problem without investigating them.

Although it has been quite a while since the release of Supercarrier, the fact that the conditions for the case, which is the most distinctive US Navy aircraft carrier operation, has been attracting attention from many players, and is written in the supercarrier operation manual, have not been implemented correctly, is even considered to be a clear indication of ED's attitude toward flight simulator development.

test_CASE_I_in_fog.miz

[Hogeo]

To clarify the conditions for each case, I created the diagram below.

Anyway, such basic things must be completed as a priority over the creation of other new mods one after another.

Sorry. I made a mistake myself, so I have corrected it.

 

null

Edited Tuesday at 02:39 PM by Hogeo