Need help on Joystick recommendation

[uboats]

Now I have T16000m and x52 throttle to setup a HOTAS

 

However, the buttons placement on T16000m is not good and the number of buttons on the stick is not enough.

 

I'm looking for a joystick for replacement. CH Pro Fighterstick is a good one for buttons, but I was told that it does not use hall effect sensor and has less axis accuracy than T16000m.

So I do not know whether it is worth to buy CH Fighterstick instead.

 

BTW, is x52 throttle or CH Pro throttle USB better? I do not use programmable software to remap the buttons. I directly set the buttons in the game