I just bought the saitek X-65f joystick yesterday.
I bought it so I could use it with Black Shark 1 but I might need to buy Black shark 2 so I have a serial number that will work the BS1 serial is saying it's broken or something so can't play it, not sure if that's due to a GFX card or the stick itself causing the need for a new serial to be needed.
For me I find it a shame as I can only use it with the A-10C and I'm not really into the A-10C sim.
The center of the stick is probably 0.02mm off the the proper center of the trim squares, you can trim this up if you wanted.
I've not really had a proper stick before so the force stick isn't a problem and in fact would probably work better if you have a tight space.
How ever seeing as you don't have Black Shark at all, and only have the A-10C then you'd be better to get the warthog stick.
The X-65f was a dearer stick for me than the warthog I could have picked either and I might still get a warthog later on down the track just to use for the A10C sim but you need to remember all the switches and stuff are pretty much made for that 1 sim sure you can use it for other stuff but you'll need to program all the switches and buttons for every other program and you might not be up for that.
The other problem is I don't think the warthog stick would be suited for the helo sims as you don't have the twist bit on the warthog, the x65f does have the twist for rudders you can select this to be on or off if you do have them.
I think the x65f is the best for the helo sims you do have the down side of needing to profile everything but you'd need to do that with warthog as well anyway but for the a10c and the tie fighter games from memory it's just the stick and 2-3 buttons at best the warthog would get you by.
Not sure about the rudder pedals I'll probably get some myself but not right now at least I'll just use the stick.
The x65f I got seems fine I have it on a desk that has lino office surface on it and the stock rubber corners seem to hold stick and throttle in place fine for me, the stiffness of the throttle seems fine to me, but I do welding and have plenty of forearm strength to shift it around. so have left it at the factory stock tightness, it also doesn't shift.
I don't have the metal plate on the x65f stick either and there's no bolts used either you can bolt the stick and the throttle I would suggest if your up for it you might be best to just drill the holes through the desk and just bolt the thing in rather than use bits of Velcro and stuff I haven't used those either by the way.
Anyway I think I've gotten the right thing for me for the helo side but I would suggest to get the warthog for the a10c if you use that sim.
The Logitech stuff could be good.
The CH stuff I didn't bother with as it's probably a bit generic and probably more based towards the flight sim X band wagon, you know for use in Learjets etc.