Personally I'm loving the additional feedback of the afterburner "fake" sound option.
Small things like this allow us some feedback of what's going on, and detail sounds are very useful no matter how "unrealistic" they may be.
I'd be okay with things going either way.
It would be nice to have a global option to have "additional unrealistic noises" for things like the gear, air brakes, (do tail hooks whistle?), AB lighting, etc.
edit - I just realized Bunny said the same thing. A slider, even as low as 3-way option would be nice.... and would be nice if it were truly global, including third-party addons.
In XPlane11 there are mods that can add multiple sound effects and overlayed to your liking which is HUGE.
In the racing sims, sounds are a make or break it situation on the edge of grip, DCS can be the same way at times. Telltale sounds no matter how unrealistic are a great option for those of us without feedback systems.
But have it AS an option is great for those that DO have feedback systems.
Thanks btd.