I owned the CH pedals for 8 years and finally replaced them 6 months ago (they only lasted that long because they spend half their life in the closet). CH pedals are complete crap. I hated them after about a year of use, as I did my CH Combatstick. They are clunky, loud, inaccurate, the toe axis only uses about 50% of physical travel making them basically on/off only, look like piss, and the software like the pedals themselves is from 1995. I dremeled them last year to remove the awful centering, but the springs are still too weak and I didn't want to go through the hassle of finding stronger ones just to have slightly less crappy pedals. I can't imagine how the Saitek ones could be worse unless they just plain don't work.
It's easy to think CH makes good products when you've never experienced an actual good product. I actually think they are a despicable company for charging what they do with no desire to improve the products. Heck they could have replaced pots with hall effect 10 years ago for almost nothing so that customers would never have to worry about lost accuracy, but they don't give a crap about customers. They are an industrial company that makes this 20 year old equipment on the side. I'm sure farm tractors have better equipment than their joystick.
Never tried the Satek pedals but I was considering them (hoping they would be better) before I decided it was stupid to replace crap with slightly better crap wasting my money, and instead bought a crosswind that I will likely never need to replace.
You have to ask yourself, "do I want to spend hundreds of dollars on something that just sort of works ok, and then replace it a few years later when it breaks or I want something better? Or should I just spend that money now and have something that I actually enjoy and works properly that I'll likely never need to replace, or at least not for the next 15 years?"