Semi philosophical post. I'm regretting so hard throwing away my Thrustmaster RCS (and FCS) three years ago. If you have them and want rid of them, for the love of <insert deity of your choice> sell them on eBay instead of throwing them away.
(not my pic, stole and rehosted it)
In my 'defense', I bought them 1996 and used them to 2001, but haven't played any games since. No computer had had a 15 pin gameport for 15 years, they took up space and I was tired of glitchy potentiometers. I figured if the mood came on, I would just get new and better gear. The spring had broken twice but I preferred no spring, no artificial 'wind pressure' by then. Now my decision hurts in the soul for the unnecessary waste.
Now, after researching, I've realized how very limited of quality products the market for this kind of stuff is. I realized how good (wide and sturdy) the RCS frame aluminum was/is. Almost every new pedal set on offer is narrow (which I hate) and done with cheap plastic components and still quite expensive. Noticing the quality of the RCS frame prevented me from throwing them away earlier but having no interest in gaming and having done no research I labored under the misconception I would have to make my own gameport-to-USB-adapter and make my own Hall-effect-modification, not realizing there was ready made gameport and Hall effect mods available already in the early 2000's.
Do I feel better stumbling across a two year old ad selling an RCS for just 30 dollar? Not really, today on eBay they go for between 50-200 dollar + shipping and fees.
If I hadn't decided to go upscale I would have gotten an old Thrustmaster RCS from eBay, gotten an gameport to USB adapter (Rockfire RM-203U, good link for someone needing this, read all of it) and tried to find an Hall effect mod (they existed). I would've bought TM RCS rudders off eBay with broken springs, cosmetic flaws and crappy potentiometer just to get the frame before buying anything new of the shelf (my plan until yesterday).
If I don't want narrow pedals and don't want crappy mechanisms there's not a lot to choose from.
"Thrustmaster TPR: Thrustmaster Pendular Rudder" are probably very good but butt ugly and hideously expensive. But those are the only new Thrustmaster pedals I would consider. Thrustmaster TFRP or Thrustmaster Elite, to narrow, to plastic.
Slaw Device pedals, beautiful, very solid all metal design (overly complicated?) but very expensive and difficult to buy, similar with Baur (BRD?). Without having tried them, I don't like the idea of the VKB-Sim mechanism and since I'm going upscale I want the full monty, toebrakes.
I think I'm going with MFG Crosswind. I gained the impression of a thorough design process (creator debugged them for years and made them very adjustable) and not as expensive as Thrustmaster TPR or Slaw pedals.