Hi.
I'm just curious what parts you feel are THAT far fetched in Top Gun.
I understand having MiGs which are actually F-5's is unrealistic. The movie was made 5 years prior to the end of the Cold War, it's not likely Hollywood would have access to a modern looking MiG.
And, OK, the HUD gun cross and missile lock symbology is probably not realistic either. It's possible, at the time, that this was classified. If anyone's got footage of F14 HUD tapes. please post a link.
There are a lot of things that are pretty realistic, like "hitting the brakes and letting him fly right by."
See the stories of Randy "Duke" Cunningham and Ray Bourgholtzer:
The two fighters separated and came back at each other again, performing two up-and-down maneuvers, trying to get on each other's tail. The MiG stayed with the Phantom every step of the way. Cunningham thought: "He's gonna get lucky one of these times."
Then Cunningham cut power and extended his airbrakes, forcing the MiG to overshoot. The MiG pilot went into a steep dive to escape and Cunningham followed. The range was long and Sidewinders could be easily confounded by ground heat sources on a downward shot, but Cunningham launched anyway. Somewhat to his surprise, the missile went home and the MiG exploded.
"Duke" Cunningham later became the commander of Top Gun. It would only make sense that he would teach what works IRL to his students, no matter how absurd it may seem.
http://www.faqs.org/docs/air/avf4_2.html
http://www.au.af.mil/au/goe/eaglebios/02bios/cunnin02.htm
Ray Bourgholtzer, who flew F7F-3Ns out of Kangnung, wrote, "I knew John Andre and he flew both F7F's and Corsairs. He was flying a Corsair when he shot down the Yak. It had come in behind him and when he realized he was being attacked. He dropped wheels and flaps, and cut the throttle. This caused the Yak to overshoot him and when he did, Andre then increased his throttle and pulled up the wheels and flaps and stayed with the Yak and shot him down with his 4 20mm cannon."
http://www.kalaniosullivan.com/KunsanAB/VM...witwasa1ac.html
As for Goose's death as a result of ejection, note the following from this Forensic Science Journal:
http://journalsip.astm.org/JOURNALS/FORENSIC/PAGES/2148.htm
"The majority of fatalities occurred during “out-of-envelope” ejections...two cases of hangman's type cervical neck fracture were observed during high-speed ejection."