I have the x56 and personally I dont mind it. I dont use the software as it has caused issues with getting command right. There is also a usb power issue that causes the software to freak out and randomly input keys or miss your inputs. I map all my controls in-game. I am looking at replacing the joystick at this point. The throttle is really nice on the x56 with all the buttons and axis but I dont like the joystick.
As a hog flyer missing the CMS thumb on the stick makes things interesting with some of the key bindings. Along with that the pivot cup that the joystick has at the base cases jinks in my movement that make it more challenging for AA Refueling and formations, etc.
While I am not the biggest fan I am not the biggest critic. I have been using for about a year and It works just fine. For a first Hotas or one on a budget it is great before going to the warthog or similar.