Ракеты в DCS

[Max1mus]

54 minutes ago, Chizh said:

Есть треки?

R-27_all_miss.trkAIM-7M_some_hit.trk

В этот раз 100% одинаковые дальности и скорости ракет.

[Chizh]

49 минут назад, Max1mus сказал:

R-27_all_miss.trkAIM-7M_some_hit.trk

В этот раз 100% одинаковые дальности и скорости ракет.

Это дело случая. 

Вот попадание Р-27 в этой же ситуации.

R-27 vs F-15 tail on.trk

[Max1mus]

3 hours ago, Chizh said:

Это дело случая. 

Вот попадание Р-27 в этой же ситуации.

R-27 vs F-15 tail on.trk 39.69 kB · 2 downloads

Смотрите на последние ракеты в моих треках. Когда я перестал диполи бросать, -7 делает поворот и попадает. Р-27 это не делают. Или ушли за диполи, или нет. 


- AIM-7. New ground clutter model also applied to all AIM-7 family missiles.

Почему это только было зделано для спаррова?

[nighthawk2174]

33 minutes ago, Max1mus said:

Смотрите на последние ракеты в моих треках. Когда я перестал диполи бросать, -7 делает поворот и попадает. Р-27 это не делают. Или ушли за диполи, или нет. 


- AIM-7. New ground clutter model also applied to all AIM-7 family missiles.

Почему это только было зделано для спаррова?

Р-27Ер все еще находится на старом ракетном коде, который, вероятно, несовместим с новыми изменениями. Следовательно, missile_data и missile_table lua вместо одного файла.

[Chizh]

3 часа назад, nighthawk2174 сказал:

Р-27Ер все еще находится на старом ракетном коде, который, вероятно, несовместим с новыми изменениями. Следовательно, missile_data и missile_table lua вместо одного файла.

Да, верно.

[Арсений]

[Breakshot]

22 hours ago, Chizh said:

Да, верно.

Это значит что будут доработаны по стандарту 7М? 

[Chizh]

1 час назад, Breakshot сказал:

Это значит что будут доработаны по стандарту 7М? 

Да, будут.

[Breakshot]

1 minute ago, Chizh said:

Да, будут.

Все, тогда ждем! Спасибо

[tavarish palkovnik]

...

Edited April 23 by tavarish palkovnik

[GGTharos]

Nicely done.  Is the white delineating the sustain grain and the cross-hatch area the boost, or is the white the void volume?

[tavarish palkovnik]

Fuel block (in my perspective) has крестообразный канал all way long but perimeter is not same.

Front side is substaining and highly boost assisting, rear side simple as that boosting only and middle differential is key for everything to have what expected.

 

 

Edited May 26, 2021 by tavarish palkovnik

[GGTharos]

Sorry, something went wrong in the translation.  I do see that you have the 'star' chamber all the way through.   Also from seeing some of the graphs previously posted it appears that the boost/sustain grain is either only slightly different, or there's no difference at all and the slight boost/sustain power difference may be made up by other means.

 

Edit:  I am asking because I am curious.  My knowledge is superficial, just enough to understand some of what you have done.   I have not attempted to do the math on rocket motor mechanics though on the surface the equations don't look that scary.

Edited May 26, 2021 by GGTharos

[Andrei]

12 hours ago, tavarish palkovnik said:

Fuel block (in my perspective) has крестообразный канал all way long but perimeter is not same.

Front side is substaining and highly boost assisting, rear side simple as that boosting only and middle differential is key for everything to have what expected.

 

 

А центральный канал белого цвета чем является? Это тоже топливо или что-то иное?

[Маэстро]

Это один из лучей звездочки в разрезе, т.е. там пустота.

[tavarish palkovnik]

....

Edited April 23 by tavarish palkovnik

[Rich]

Any ETA on when the AIM-120 will receive HOJ effects?

[Chizh]

2 часа назад, Rich сказал:

Any ETA on when the AIM-120 will receive HOJ effects?

120s have HOJ

[Rich]

4 hours ago, Chizh said:

120s have HOJ

Can 120's loft against a jamming target in reality? Deka's SD-10 doesn't loft on a jamming target and is a newer missile

Edited June 6, 2021 by Rich

[GGTharos]

42 minutes ago, Rich said:

Can 120's loft against a jamming target in reality? Deka's SD-10 can't loft on a jamming target and is a newer missile

 

The only thing that matter is the available information, not which missile is newer.  Lack of loft is due to denial of range.  Yep, probably the 120 should be doing something similar unless there's some way to inform it of the range or if it uses a lofting technique to deal with it.

[Rich]

9 minutes ago, GGTharos said:

 

The only thing that matter is the available information, not which missile is newer.  Lack of loft is due to denial of range.  Yep, probably the 120 should be doing something similar unless there's some way to inform it of the range or if it uses a lofting technique to deal with it.

I always see missile introduction date argued here as the main way of comparing capability between missile so I apologize if this doesn't follow. Can you go into more detail on "if it uses a lofting technique to deal with it"?

[BlackPixxel]

1 hour ago, Chizh said:

120s have HOJ

 

The HOJ appears to give the missile perfect guidance. It lofts as if it was fired on a non-jamming target without support.

 

Fired on a jamming target beyond burn through range the missile should propably not loft, it has no range information for that.

[GGTharos]

1 hour ago, Rich said:

I always see missile introduction date argued here as the main way of comparing capability between missile so I apologize if this doesn't follow. Can you go into more detail on "if it uses a lofting technique to deal with it"?

 

It's just geometry using the look angle as opposed a more efficient loft.   None of this applies to DCS.

As to why the date isn't important here - as far as dates go it's all about which missiles were being used in the same time period for most arguments.   Generally, loft is triggered if range information is available, and it's not exactly a new technique.

Edited June 5, 2021 by GGTharos

[Chizh]

13 часов назад, Rich сказал:

Can 120's loft against a jamming target in reality? 

 

We don't know. 

Without knowing the range, it is difficult to set the correct loft trajectory to save energy. We will remove the loft in this case.

[FoxAlfa]

14 minutes ago, Chizh said:

We don't know. 

Without knowing the range, it is difficult to set the correct loft trajectory to save energy. We will remove the loft in this case.

Can also R-27, R-77 HOJ be changed from Pure to Proportional Navigation?